Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8  Next

J.D. Crawford wrote:
Tim Lison wrote:
I know it'll add to the price, but silver inlay would really look great with this sword. I can't recall seeing an engraved sword without inlay but I'm no expert! If jeff were to leave the fuller a bit dark and polish the inlay it would really stand out...


Well Tim, Peter Johnsson agrees with you, so who am I to argue? Jeff is going to do the inlay in fine silver.

You guys!!!


So happy to read this!

Inlay is the best!

I can't stand ingraving on earlier swords and etching. . . . just eww. . . . . .

This is going to be a spectacular piece!
You're all right of course, might as well do it right and have something to be proud of.

I'm quite happy with the advice and decision. The original intent was to keep the budget down and sell a couple of swords to raise the funds, but I ended up selling 3 (some of you know what I mean) so there were funds left over anyway.

Now we have to wait a bit more...at least until the silver arrives in Jeff's hands.
Buahahaha, we are so cruel. :) But the sword will be glorious. ;)
J.D. Crawford wrote:
You're all right of course, might as well do it right and have something to be proud of.

I'm quite happy with the advice and decision. The original intent was to keep the budget down and sell a couple of swords to raise the funds, but I ended up selling 3 (some of you know what I mean) so there were funds left over anyway.

Now we have to wait a bit more...at least until the silver arrives in Jeff's hands.
Preach it brother... I ended up selling a pretty expensive rifle to fund my project. I haven't been shooting much so its not a big loss. Custom sword is cooler than a mass produced rifle anyway (though it was a Steyr AUG, so it was cool rifle). Definitely understand about doing it right and having something to be proud of though.

After Jeff does my sword, I have another scabbard project lined up with Brian Kunz, but after that you guys have to talk me down... Atleast for alittle while. My wallet is aching :D

Glad you decided on the inlay... As Luka said, its gonna be glorious
Good choice on the inlay. It's the right thing to do! Oh, and we're not being cruel. If we were being cruel we would have recommended doing gold inlay! ;)
So it goes. In the mean time, I wonder about the meaning of the inscription: + NEDEHER EWEDENI + +

This does not appear to be Latin or any easily recognizeable religeous invocation. I did a bit of research and came to these partially-formed ideas:

NEDEHER
- could be an acronym
- the semi-repetitive NE DE RE is reminiscent of some repetitive medieval sword inscriptions like ANTANT or TOTO
- similar to German NEHER (middle) or Jewish NEDER (sort of a religious vow).
- a google search reveals several current latin surnames with this spelling so it could be a proper name

EWEDENI
- sounds to me like a proper name, something like Edwin
- similar to Nigernian proper name Ewedemi
- contains most letters of 'Sweden', but seems unlikely that S would be missing.
- similar to a Czech word for seduction (again seems rather unlikely).

Either could be a mis-spelling like on older swords, although one might think 14th century artisans to be more literate

If anyone has insights into this phrase, I would be very interested to hear about it.

-JD
Stop the press, I just translated the description from the Cluny display (its one of the pictures on the Vikverir site). Here's what it says in French:

"Epee
Oakeshott XVI
Cette epee, munie d'une lame a gorge etroit et a pointe vive, est efficace aussi bien de taille que d'estoc, surtout lor de combats engages au fer.
Europe de l'Ouest XIV Siecle
Alliage ferreux, cuivre, or"

Which I translate as (francophones help me out here):

"Sword
Oakeshott XVI
This sword, with a narrow fuller and lively balance, is effective both in cutting and thrusting, and specialized for fighting against metal armour.
Western Europe XIV Century
Ferrous alloy, copper, gold"

(My italics)

First, not silver, but copper and gold. (A Kingly sword!). I can't do gold, but maybe we should use copper and/or some other gold substitute rather than silver. I need to confer with Jeff about this.

Second they call it an XVI. This implies a diamond shaped ridge toward the tip. I cannot see this from the photos. It looks like the blade is quite flat at the end of the fuller. However, it might be reenforced for thrusting near the tip. Or maybe they called it XVI just because its quite pointy toward the tip. One would need to see a close-up to be sure.

-JD
J.D. Crawford wrote:
Stop the press, I just translated the description from the Cluny display (its one of the pictures on the Vikverir site). Here's what it says in French:

"Epee
Oakeshott XVI
Cette epee, munie d'une lame a gorge etroit et a pointe vive, est efficace aussi bien de taille que d'estoc, surtout lor de combats engages au fer.
Europe de l'Ouest XIV Siecle
Alliage ferreux, cuivre, or"

Which I translate as (francophones help me out here):

"Sword
Oakeshott XVI
This sword, with a narrow fuller and lively balance, is effective both in cutting and thrusting, and specialized for fighting against metal armour.
Western Europe XIV Century
Ferrous alloy, copper, gold"

(My italics)

First, not silver, but copper and gold. (A Kingly sword!). I can't do gold, but maybe we should use copper and/or some other gold substitute rather than silver. I need to confer with Jeff about this.

Second they call it an XVI. This implies a diamond shaped ridge toward the tip. I cannot see this from the photos. It looks like the blade is quite flat at the end of the fuller. However, it might be reenforced for thrusting near the tip. Or maybe they called it XVI just because its quite pointy toward the tip. One would need to see a close-up to be sure.

-JD


You could use Brass/latten, which is seen on quite a few swords of the 1300's. I don't believe we see copper inlays at that time quite as much. I off the top of my head, know a type XIIa with a cross inlayed in copper on the pommel.

I find brass inlay quite attractive.
So, slight change of plans. We're going to go with bronze inlay. Not to save money (other than gold, material is not the major expense here), but rather to capture the visual essence of the 'copper and gold' mentioned in the Cluny exhibit. Also, I'm sure silver would be very elegant, but I want the letters to 'pop' for the eye. We'll see how it works out.
Bronze will look great. Pure copper would also look very good I think but I don't know if pure copper inlays were used on blades...
What about Brass/Latten? I know you don't wanna have to keep making changes, but brass/latten is very appropriate for inlays in this period and will look quite similar.
All good ideas folks, but I don't want to jerk Jeff around anymore. I think he would have preferred silver, but I was influenced by the Cluny museum description and out the 'yellow metal' choices he likes working with bronze, so there you go.

No scholarly thoughts on the meaning of the inscription?
Jeff is gonna come in this thread and tell us to pipe down, we're making his job harder. :eek:

:D

With the price of gold these days, that inlay would have cost more than the rest of the sword...
While others talk, Helmes does...
"Here is a pic of the pre-heat treat rough grind. It is slightly wider and thicker than the finished blade will be but it is close."


 Attachment: 137.27 KB
P5150341m.JPG

Now Jeff has finished the rough grind and has marked in guidelines for the cutting the letters.


 Attachment: 104.37 KB
P5160368m.JPG


 Attachment: 88.22 KB
P5160366-1m.JPG

This is SO awesome!! :eek:
Thats gonna look awesome...
I could say I'm looking forward to seeing the actual inlay, but that would be understatement of the year! Thanks guys for convincing me to do this! (Or more accurately, fund this, I'm just sitting on a chair watching like the rest of you).
J.D. Crawford wrote:
I could say I'm looking forward to seeing the actual inlay, but that would be understatement of the year! Thanks guys for convincing me to do this! (Or more accurately, fund this, I'm just sitting on a chair watching like the rest of you).
Two way street friend... Atleast we'll be broke with cool swords.

Anything on the reverse?
It's really going to be great. I'm used to inlays on earlier blades but I really like the combination of this blade and inlay.
Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8  Next

Page 2 of 8

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum




All contents © Copyright 2003-2006 myArmoury.com — All rights reserved
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum